From the Lawton Constitution
By James Finck, Ph.D.
Last month I wrote about a little trip I took driving from Virginia to Oklahoma. Before I left I wanted to find a Zen type of book to listen to so I decided to reread, or in this case listen to, Norman Maclean’s “A River Runs Through It.”
I love the opening line in the book were Maclean writes “In our family, there was no clear line between religion and flyfishing.” The story is about family, faith, love, and the things that sometimes go unspoken mainly between brothers, but more importantly for me right now, between fathers and sons. It’s also about fishing. Set against the rivers and mountains of Montana, it tells the story of a family whose lives are shaped by a father, a man whose influence extends far beyond the lessons he intentionally teaches.
This book touched me differently this time because, in so many ways, it described my life and my own family. There is the free-spirited, outdoorsman brother who rebels against his father’s fishing techniques, only to become a true master angler. Then there is the more conservative, down-to-earth brother who follows all the rules. He can fish, but not as well as his brother. Instead, he likes to write and becomes a professor. Three men in this book. Three different paths. But there is no question that there is love between them all.
This book hits me particularly hard right now as we have placed my father in hospice care, and it looks like he may become bedridden. This is hard because my dad is the strongest man I have ever known, and I mean that in every way possible. Like Maclean’s father, mine taught me what it meant to be a man, not by lecturing me, but by the way he lived his life and the values he instilled in me.
Dad also taught me to fish. Some of my earliest and fondest memories of him are from the time we lived in Utah, when he would wake up before dawn to take my brother and me fishing up one of the canyons. He always laughed because he rarely put a line in the water. He was too busy helping us, and before he knew it, we had reached our trout limit. At the time, I didn’t understand how important those moments were. Children rarely do. We assume our fathers will always be there, that there will always be another conversation, another lesson, and another opportunity to tell them something we should have said years ago.
Growing older has a way of changing that perspective. Now, instead, I take my sons fishing. There were days when I didn’t always want to go, but when your teenage son says, “Dad, want to go fishing?” there is no way I could ever say no. I only get to see my dad once or twice a year and what I wouldn’t give now to cast a line in a mountain reservoir with him again.
In Maclean’s story, as in my own, fishing is about much more than fishing. It is a way for fathers to connect with their sons, and brothers with siblings. It’s a means of teaching patience, discipline, faith, and an appreciation for the world around them. The lessons are not always delivered through lectures. Sometimes they come through shared experiences, quiet moments, and simply watching the way a man lives his life. Sometimes there are things sons can say around a campfire or while sitting at a fishing hole that they could never say at home.
My father taught me in much the same way. Maybe not always while fishing, but on a long car ride or on horseback. Often, it was by going to help a neighbor or someone from church when I was not in the mood. He probably was not either, but it never showed. I may not have recognized it at the time, but those experiences helped shape the person I’ve become. My dad is the hardest worker I’ve ever known. I doubt I measure up, but he did teach me that when you are in the service of your fellow beings, you are only in the service of God. Most importantly, Dad has taught me to love God.
One of the difficult truths about being a son is that we often spend our younger years trying to find our own way. We establish our own identities, develop our own opinions, and sometimes think we can do things better than our fathers.
Then, somewhere along the way, we begin to recognize how much of them we carry with us and how right they often were. We hear ourselves repeating their expressions. We find ourselves responding to problems the way they would have. We pass their stories along to our own children. And sometimes, in a moment when we least expect it, we recognize that a value we thought we had discovered for ourselves was something our fathers had taught us all along.
As I prepare myself for a world without my father, I find myself thinking about all the things I know and all the things I still wish I knew. One thing I wish I inherited from him was his ability to fix anything. I can fix simple things, thanks to YouTube, but even with videos, whenever I start a job, the first thing I do is call my dad. I can’t count the number of projects he has walked me through. I wish I had had more patience when I was younger to listen to him more and soak up some of that knowledge.
I am grateful that, over the last several years, one subject we have talked about extensively is our family’s history. There have been many nights spent going through my grandfather’s and great-grandfather’s books of remembrance. My dad telling me hundreds of stories about their lives and his own.
Over the summer, we had one of those nights. It was late, and I had heard many of those stories before, but I am so grateful for the opportunity to sit with him one more time. This summer Dad knew he was getting sick, and he packed up all those books, all those memories, and sent me home with them. They are now some of my most prized possessions.
There is no easy way to prepare for losing a parent. And I hope he will still be around for a long while. But as I try to come to terms with the future and recognize the inevitability of mortality, my wish is for just a little more time. Perhaps that is why “A River Runs Through It” resonates so deeply with me. The river continues to flow, even as the people who once stood beside it grow older and eventually disappear. The world moves forward. Children become parents. Parents become memories. But something remains in the stories we tell, the lessons we remember, and the lives we lead.
In the end, a father’s greatest legacy may not be what he leaves behind, but what he leaves within us. The river keeps flowing. I will teach these same lessons to my sons, who will teach them to theirs.
“Eventually, all things merge into one, and a river runs through it.”
James Finck is a professor of American history at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma. He can be reached at james.finck@swoknews.com.
