From the Lawton Constitution
By James Finck, Ph.D.
I had the great honor of speaking last week, just before Veterans Day, before the Southwest Oklahoma Military Officers Association of America. It was a great group of heroes who do so many wonderful things for the city of Lawton.
As I spoke with several of the members, many expressed their appreciation for this running series I have been writing over the past month about Israel. What I have found is that, with such a complicated history and the circumstances surrounding that nation today, there are simply too many false narratives out there. People want to know the truth.
That has been my goal: To present the historical truth of this region with as little propaganda as possible. I hope I am achieving that and I am grateful to my editors for allowing me to continue.
In my last column, I described the creation of the five mandates that helped draw the map of the modern Middle East. France was given control over the mandates of Syria and Lebanon, while Britain was given the mandates of Iraq, Transjordan, and most important for our story, Palestine. I want to stress again that while there had always been regions called Syria, Lebanon, and Palestine, they never had been sovereign states until after WWI. People never had referred to themselves as Lebanese, Iraqis, Jordanians, or Palestinas until after these nations were formed.
I also want to stress that again, ethnically, the people living in the Mandate of Palestine were diverse and could trace their ancestry back to various peoples who had conquered and settled the region over the centuries. Yet for our story we are focusing on the Arabs and the Jews. As for the Palestinian Arabs, genetically some much of their ancestry is rooted in the ancient populations of the Levant, although their language and broader cultural identity today is Arab. The only reason I bring this up is that Arabs did not originate in Palestine. The Arabs began conquering the region in the 7th century AD.
As for the Jews, they, too, can trace much of their ancestry back to the ancient populations of the Levant; however, because Jewish communities were scattered throughout the world for centuries, modern Jewish populations also reflect centuries of ancestry from Europe, North Africa, and other regions. What we have most recently been discussing is the return of Jews from these distant communities to their ancestral homeland. So far, there have been three major waves of immigration, or aliyot, and what I want to examine today is the Fourth Aliyah (1924-1929).
Each of the aliyot was different in terms of the primary groups that arrived and their reasons for doing so. The Fourth Aliyah began in 1924 and brought approximately 80,000 to 85,000 Jewish immigrants to Palestine. Like the first three waves, most came from Eastern Europe, but this wave was heavily Polish. The earlier waves had been driven by a combination of religious attachment to Zion, political persecution, and socialist and agricultural movements. The Fourth Aliyah, however, was motivated more by economic and political circumstances.
One motivation for immigration to Zion was that nations were passing new immigration laws limiting Jewish immigration. The United States, for example, passed the Emergency Quota Act of 1921, which established numerical limits based on national origin. These restrictions were tightened further by the Immigration Act of 1924, making it increasingly difficult for Jews from Eastern Europe to immigrate to America. At the same time, anti-Semitism, economic discrimination, and government policies in Poland made life increasingly difficult for its Jewish population. Palestine, consequently, became a more attractive destination.
This wave was different from those who had arrived during previous ones. Many were middle-class, tradesmen, artisans, and small business owners rather than idealistic socialists from Russia seeking to establish agricultural communities. This new group brought financial resources and commercial experience that helped diversify the developing economy of Palestine. Their arrival contributed significantly to the expansion of urban Jewish communities in cities like Tel Aviv and Haifa.
However, this growing Jewish population also created growing tensions between the Jewish and Arab populations. The increasing numbers of Jewish immigrants and the amount of land being purchased from Arab landowners worried many Arabs. In August 1929, a fight broke out over control of the Western Wall and Temple Mount in Jerusalem leading to Arab rioters attacking Jewish communities throughout Palestine. One of the worst incidents occurred in Hebron, where 67 Jews were murdered and the surviving Jewish community was evacuated by the British. By the time the violence ended, approximately 133 Jews and 116 Arabs had been killed.
The violence reinforced the Jewish community’s determination to strengthen its defensive organizations, particularly the Haganah. Haganah, which is Hebrew for “defense,” was a paramilitary organization established in 1920 to protect Jewish communities. Initially, it operated as a loosely organized defense force, but it gradually developed into a more sophisticated military organization with training, weapons, and a command structure. During the 1930s and 1940s, it became the principal military organization of the Jewish community and eventually formed the foundation of the Israel Defense Forces.
The Arabs also attempted to create their own defense forces but struggled because of the lack of a unified national political organization. Their armed groups remained fragmented, often organized around local leaders, powerful families, and competing political factions. While there was a growing Palestinian Arab national identity, there was no comparable centralized political leadership yet.
While the Fourth Aliyah lasted only about five years, it played an important role in the development of modern Israel. Its immigrants helped transform the Jewish community from a primarily agricultural society into a more diversified economic and urban community. The growth of Tel Aviv, the expansion of commerce and industry, and the increasing sophistication of Jewish institutions helped the Jewish community develop more rapidly as an organized society. This helped lay the economic and social foundations for a future Jewish state. At the same time, the violence of 1929 demonstrated the competing national aspirations of Jews and Arabs.
Those tensions become even more pronounced during the Fifth Aliyah and the years leading up to World War II.
James Finck is a professor of American history at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma. He can be reached at james.finck@swoknews.com.
