Historical Election? Examining mainstream media’s spin on American History

From the Lawton Constitution

By James Finck, Ph.D.

This month we experienced a truly historic election as the blue wave washed over our nation. At least, that is what the news keeps telling us.

This election reminds me of why I started writing this column. I kept hearing the media refer to everything as “historic,” and “the first time we had seen anything like …” whatever they were reporting on.

Yes, this election was historic, if you consider every democratic election historic in its own way, but it was not unprecedented. Seven midterms, and possibly eight, depending on what happens in Alaska and Mississippi, have had larger waves in midterm elections since 1858. Now, seven is still historic, I suppose, but if you listen to mainstream media, you’d assume this was the largest wave ever.

As a political historian who offers a two-semester class on political parties and elections or at least used to offer them before the new rules at my college, I knew Republicans were going to lose seats in Congress. How did I know? Because the sitting president’s party almost always loses seats.

A few years back, I wrote an article that looked at every midterm election before a sitting president won reelection, beginning in 1932. I only counted presidents who won their first election, not those who became president because of a death. Those presidents were FDR, Eisenhower, Nixon, Reagan, Clinton, George W. Bush, and Obama.

In each midterm election before they won reelection, their party lost seats in the House of Representatives. The only two exceptions were FDR’s first term and Bush. That means that 77% of the time, presidents who were popular enough to win reelection still lost seats during the midterm. In other words, it is hard to use midterm elections as predictors of the next presidential election.

This election is different from the one I discussed in my last article because Trump is not allowed to run in 2028. Since this is a different scenario, it might be interesting to look at midterm elections during the second terms of presidents to see if history can help predict the next presidential election. Since the FDR elections are out of the ordinary, as he served three terms, was elected to his fourth and died shortly thereafter, I decided to start with Truman. I also decided to look only at the House, since only one-third of the Senate is up for reelection each election cycle.

In 1948, Truman won a surprise reelection. In the following midterm election in 1950, the Democratic Party lost 28 seats in the House. In the 1952 election, the White House switched from blue to red as Eisenhower won 442 to 89. This is a difficult election to use as a comparison because Eisenhower was arguably the most popular man in America after WWII. If he had run on the Democratic ticket, as Democrats had hoped, then the Democrats likely would have won. Yet it was still a midterm loss followed by a loss in the next presidential election.

Ike went on to win reelection in 1956, but in the 1958 midterms, his party lost 48 seats in the House, a larger loss than this past midterm. The trend continued as the White House switched from red to blue when Kennedy beat Nixon 303 to 219. So far, two for two.

The next two-term president was Lyndon Johnson, who won reelection in 1964 after taking over for Kennedy. During his second term, his party lost 47 seats in the House in the 1966 midterm, again a larger loss than in 2026. The trend continued as the White House switched from blue to red when Nixon won the presidency in 1968 with 301 electoral votes to Humphrey’s 191. So far, three for three.

Nixon went on to have one of the most lopsided victories in presidential history when he won in 1972, but then lost 48 seats in the House in the 1974 midterm. While this election follows the pattern we are seeing, it also needs an asterisk. By the next election, Nixon would have resigned because of the Watergate scandal. However, in November 1972, seven men had been indicted for the break-in, but the trial had not yet started, and nothing had tied Nixon directly to the case. So, while the pattern still holds, as the presidency flipped in 1976 with Carter’s victory, the Democrats were certainly in a strong position after the scandal. Yet the pattern still holds true, the president’s party lost seats in his second midterm, and the other party won the presidency. Now we are four for four.

We see something similar with President Reagan. He won reelection by a staggering margin in 1984, but then lost seats in the House during the 1986 midterms. While it was only four seats, it was still a loss. The difference was that, for the first time, we saw a party retain the presidency when George H.W. Bush beat Michael Dukakis 426 to 111. Now we are four for five.

Clinton is up next. After a successful reelection, he also lost just four seats, like Reagan, but it was still a loss. Once again, the pattern held as the White House switched in 2000 from blue to red with George W. Bush’s 271 to 266 victory bringing the count to five out of six.

As I mentioned before, Bush was the rare exception during his first midterm election, when Republicans actually gained seats in the House. But after a successful reelection, he lost 30 seats in the House in the 2006 midterms. Then, just as before, Democrats took back the presidency with Obama’s 365 to 173 victory. This election brings the count to six out of seven.

Finally, we see the pattern hold true one more time. Obama won reelection only to lose 13 seats in the House in 2014. Then, following his presidency, the Republicans claimed victory with Trump’s 304 to 227 electoral vote win in 2016.

It does not bode well for Republicans, as it is hard to argue with seven out of eight elections in which two-term presidents lost seats in their second midterm and the other party won the next presidential election. Maybe, after eight years of one party in charge, Americans simply like to mix things up. Seven out of eight seems to support that.

The one caveat for the 2028 election is that Trump’s two terms were not consecutive. Having a Democratic president between his two terms may soften the burnout, but we only have one presidential example to help us predict what might happen.

In 1884, Grover Cleveland had an extremely rare victory for a Democrat. As usual, Democrats lost seats in the 1886 midterm elections, but in this case, Cleveland lost to Benjamin Harrison two years later. However, like Trump, Cleveland came back strong four years later and recaptured the White House in 1892, becoming the first president to serve nonconsecutive terms.

Yet, if history repeats itself, things look bleak for Republicans. In Cleveland’s second midterm election, the Democrats lost 125 seats, the largest loss in history. In the following presidential election, the Democrats were kicked out of office until Wilson won in 1912. In other words, nonconsecutive presidential terms appear to follow the same pattern as consecutive ones.

Either way, history seems to suggest that Democrats will win the presidency in 2028. But in this time of extreme candidates and unpredictable elections, Republicans can always look to 1988 and quote Lloyd Christmas, “So, you’re saying I have a chance? YEAH!”

James Finck is a professor of American history at the University of Science and Arts of Oklahoma. He can be reached at james.finck@swoknews.com.

https://www.swoknews.com/community_news/column-historical-election-examining-mainstream-media-s-spin-on-american-history/article_f4bfdfc3-fa12-567b-92e4-cbda391fabd4.html

Leave a Reply